Speak to a specialist solicitor at our law firm in North Yorkshire.
Options if my supplier does not meet my quality requirements
Failure to meet quality standards by your supplier can have a serious impact on your business, especially in an age when customer satisfaction ratings are essential. Critical problems could lead to health and safety concerns for your business, or may involve an expensive product recall. If your supplier fails to meet the quality standard you were expecting, what can you do to resolve this?
Your options will depend upon a number of factors, and how you proceed needs to be carefully thought through. Some suppliers may be more vital to you than others. For example, a supplier of rare component parts might be almost impossible to replace, and so you may wish to tread very carefully with them. A supplier who simply supplies your office stationery, however, is much easier to replace if necessary. Manufactured goods with a long lead time for production, or which are shipped from overseas, may be harder to replace in the necessary timeframe than products which can be procured quickly or locally.
It is essential that a quality failure by a supplier is addressed by you in accordance with the law and with any contractual agreement you have with your supplier. You do not want to inadvertently risk being the party that is in breach of contract by terminating a contract for an issue that does not allow for termination. Equally, you need to ensure your own business and reputation does not suffer any unnecessary disruption. Some issues can be fairly minor and can be resolved through discussion or negotiation. Other issues can be so significant that they can cause a fundamental breakdown between you and your supplier. Either way, you need to deal with this situation proactively to ensure a return to the smooth running of your business.
In this blog we look at what you can do if your supplier fails to meet your quality requirements, what might be considered a fundamental problem compared to a minor breach, and the most effective way of resolving problems between you and your supplier.
When might a supplier fail to meet your quality requirements?
Quality failures can happen in many different ways:
- if the supplier uses substandard, maybe cheaper, materials than the ones agreed upon, and which may be different to the sample provided originally;
- where there has been a general lack of attention to quality detail, such as sending items that do not comply with the specification agreed upon, or the plans provided for the goods;
- poor workmanship is a frequent problem, where products are poorly put together, or poorly packaged, resulting in an unacceptable appearance or poor performance;
- failure to meet relevant legal, industry, safety, certification or regulatory standards – a serious example would be where a supplier fails to meet food quality standards by failing to label food correctly, leading to allergic reactions with potentially fatal results; or
- failure to supply quality IT equipment under an IT supply agreement can cause a serious knock on effect to a company if their IT system is inefficient as a result.
What evidence will you need?
If you wish to reject a consignment, pay less for a consignment, or ultimately end an agreement because you believe your supplier has failed to meet your agreed and expected quality requirements, you must first show what the expected quality requirements are. The starting point for this is usually the contract that you have with your supplier. This should set out what is being supplied, and the terms of supply. If it is well drafted, it will go into detail showing your expectations and what standards must be met.
Also vital will be copies of order forms, delivery forms, and invoices. These are essential to show what it was that you were expecting, and when, so that when this does not happen, you are clear on the nature of the problem. If you were provided with a sample during your negotiations, then this will be good evidence of the quality that you agreed upon.
You should keep records of correspondence where you complain about problems, as well as keeping records of the response to those complaints. These can be invaluable if the dispute escalates.
If this is not the first time that quality standards have been a problem, then you should keep notes of emails and phone conversations between you and the supplier and review these together with your solicitor.
What are your options?
It is important that you let the supplier know there is a problem as soon as possible, and if it is reasonable to do so, to let them rectify this. How this might be rectified to your satisfaction will depend on the goods supplied and the quality problem. You might reject the delivery altogether and refuse to pay until a replacement is provided. Due to the disruption to your business, you may be able to insist upon an additional cost reduction.
The terms of the supply agreement can dictate what your options are. A well drafted agreement may provide remedies for certain situations. How you approach this will be on a commercial as well as legal basis. If this is a rare mistake, but the supplier is usually reliable and provides a high quality service, then you might want to resolve this with them to avoid having to end a contract and find another supplier, with all the problems that can entail.
If the agreement allows for some room for error, then terminating a contract for a minor error might even lead to a claim against you for unlawful termination, so you must check the terms before making any decisions.
However, if quality does not improve, despite the supplier being given the opportunity to rectify it, you may have grounds to terminate the contract.
Equally the breach might be so serious that it is necessary to terminate the contract and source an alternative supplier. While this is not a decision to be taken lightly, if you decide that this supplier cannot consistently meet the required quality standards, termination of the contract might be the only option. You may also have grounds for damages for loss of business or reputation.
Dispute resolution options
The first option is to try to resolve the matter between you. This will often lead to a swift solution, and may allow for a contract to continue if this is the desired result.
If this is not possible, the next step is to write to the supplier, clearly setting out what the problem is, and giving a reasonable timeframe for it to be rectified, if this is possible. What is reasonable will depend on the damage being caused by the breach of standards. Even if this does not get you the results you need, you will have started the dispute resolution process.
Your contract may specify how disputes must be resolved, and this should be checked. This may say that an alternative dispute resolution process, such as mediation or arbitration, must be used first. These methods can be advantageous, as they are less adversarial than the standard court procedures, and may help to preserve an ongoing relationship with your supplier, which can be vital if they are not easy to replace. They can also be a cheaper option than choosing the court route, and can take place quickly.
If these methods do not work, then you might have to bring a claim in court against the supplier for breach of contract. The court has wide powers to make a suitable order if they find that a breach has taken place. The supplier may be ordered to make good the problem, by delivering the goods you require, or by replacing faulty goods for example. They may instead, or in addition to this, be ordered to pay damages to you, depending on what the fault is and what the loss was to your business. This is another very good reason for maintaining detailed records, so that you can show what losses you have suffered if required. Perhaps this might be a loss of customers, or a clear reduction in turnover as a result of the quality problems. It might be that you have had to settle a claim brought against you from a customer, as a result of a substandard product.
How can we help?
Our specialist dispute resolution solicitors can work with you to ensure a quality problem with a supplier are resolved as quickly as possible, with the least disruption to your business.
For assistance, please contact a legal adviser in our dispute resolution team on 01904 624185.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Please note that the law may have changed since this article was published.

















